Holly asks Gary to trick Henry into meeting with her, but the plan backfires and strains the bonds of friendship among all of them. Elsewhere, Valerie swears off sugar and tries to persuade Lauren to join her.

Holly's ready to date Vince after seeing Henry with a new girl, but her plans are derailed when she finds Vince with someone else. Elsewhere, Gary gets a new job at a store that requires him to work shirtless, much to the delight of female customers.