A wrench is thrown in Mignini's case and the search for a new suspect - Rudy Guede - begins. As the highly anticipated trial unfolds, Amanda's choices continue to be scrutinized by the press.

After the verdict, Amanda falls into a depression, resigning herself to making the best of life in prison. As her appeal approaches and new facts come to light, Amanda decides she will not make the same mistakes that she made in her first trial.