As churchgoers flourish in numbers, Reverend Dan soothes the anxieties of the townspeople. When the hauntings escalate to a possession of a young boy, Dan wrestles with the thought of performing an unsanctioned exorcism.

As Val organizes a civil defense force to protect the town, her twin daughter Abigail goes missing. Jimmy leads the charge to find the young girl, employing Roman's medium skills and anyone else who's willing to set foot in the treacherous forest on the outskirts of town.