Supergirl discovers that she has a mental link to Sam and Julia, and takes Lena and Alex with her to rescue them. Meanwhile, James faces a tough decision when he must decide whether to investigate Lena or not after she kept Reign's existence a secret.

Followers of Coville plan to use his journal to create a new Worldkiller. Meanwhile, Supergirl tries to repair the rift between her and Lena, and James is forced to consider whether to out himself or not.