Guests: Ryan Reilly, Barbara McQuade, Rep. Jamie Raskin, Sen. Peter Welch, Jessica Valenti

The Proud Boys will stand back and stand by for sentencing. Tonight: the guilty verdict for Donald Trump's foot soldiers. And Congressman Jamie Raskin on the connective tissue from the leaders of the mob to the man who sent them. Then, another Supreme Court ethics blockbuster: the same mega-donor treating Clarence Thomas to lavish vacations and paying his mother's rent is caught paying the private school tuition for the child Thomas raised as a son. Plus, the prosecution rests in the Trump civil rape trial as the accused is offered a second chance to testify. And the mysterious case of a formerly pro-abortion North Carolina Democrat now suddenly voting with Republicans to restrict abortion access.

Guests: Andre Bernstein, Jane Manning, Josh Gerstein, Rep. Dan Goldman, Sarah Longwell, Molly Jong-Fast, Brittney Cooper

A jury finds Donald Trump liable for sexual abuse and defamation. Tonight: Vindication for E. Jean Carroll, the fallout for the Republican front-runner, and the reaction from the Republican Party. Plus federal charges for freshman congressman and serial liar George Santos.

Note: All In didn't air on Monday, May 9.  Instead there was an MSNBC special.