Josh and Nick coach their friend Luke on how to amicably break up with his girlfriend, Sydney, so that it won't jeopardize Josh's spot in her coveted spin class. Also, Judy and Harry invite their rivals, Dick and Lenore Stevenson, over to play bridge, and Andrew and Eve celebrate their anniversary with their own gift-giving tradition.

After Harry scales back to a four day work week, Josh suggests he take an acting class on Fridays to avoid spending the day together, however Josh gets frustrated when Harry refuses to break character at home. Also, after Judy is called back to her doctor's office for another test, she's convinced she is dying and spills secrets she doesn't want to take to her grave.