Tyler and Jay return to New Haven to retrieve items that may exonerate them from the terrorist bombing and implicate Will Traveler instead. Meanwhile, Carlton Fog issues a press conference regarding his involvement in hiding his son, and Kim's daily life begins to crumble as she searches for proof of the ever elusive Will.

Tyler and Jay find a security box with Will Traveler's aliases and evidence about the bombing. Meanwhile Will returns, only to be captured and interrogated by his bosses, and the FBI makes a key arrest that shows the Drexler conspiracy goes way beyond Jay and Tyler.