Elliott's brother Donnie returns as a successful insurance salesman in need of a loan. Maya, however, remains convinced that Donnie is up to his old tricks, even when he is beaten up. Jack and the rest of the staff discover that silence is not always a good thing.

When Finch reunites with his childhood friend, he is shocked to learn that he had a sex change and is now a woman named Brandi. Elliot gets back at Nina for treating her assistant badly.