Emily meets her ex-boyfriend Ramon to catch up. He invites her to his home for a reunion with their school friends. As she reminisces on carefree times with her old buddies, a familiar face stops her in her tracks.

As Emily and Vince enjoy their secret island getaway, their respective families grow worried about their whereabouts. Vince's parents and Emily's husband Frank begin a search for the missing pair. Stones are turned and the unexpected lovers' secrets come to light.