Reporter Caryn Lieberman tells the story of the 1994 disappearance of Larry Arnold, a man who went missing from Toronto's gay village. Arnold's body wasn't found until weeks later, discovered in an area 'known for sexual cruising.' We hear the frustration of family members, who feel investigators initially didn't take the case seriously enough. Until...police got a break that would change everything. Larry Arnold wasn't this killer's only victim.

On a cold, snowy winter night in January 2008 an officer was on patrol when a confusing call came in to 911. A hardworking mother of five disappeared while on her way home from work– to make matters worse– there were indications she was being attacked. Investigators raced against the clock to find Arcelie Laoagan. Follow along on this frantic search as the officer shares the horrific discovery that haunts him to this day.