As Elizabeth struggles to start her writing about her life in Hope Valley, she is also starting to become jealous of Jack's budding friendship with Faith. Abigail aids Pastor Frank in helping nearby settlers who are down on their luck. Meanwhile, following his injury, Lee has to deal with Rosemary's overbearing protectiveness and trying to figure out who is sabotaging his lumber business.

Abigail endures anguish when the children's aunt arrives and a parting seems inevitable. However, while staying in Hope Valley in which she spends time getting to know Cody and Becky, the citizens of Hope Valley observe a powerful act of love when Charlotte realizes that what is best for them is to stay with Abigail. Rosemary receives a movie offer that causes her to contemplate leaving Hope Valley.