In an effort to make Miss Bitterman a happier person, Sonny decides she and Marshall would be the perfect couple. The plan works and all seems to be going well until Miss Bitterman gets more involved with the So Random! sketches than the cast would like.

Chad alerts the So Random! cast that he has been given his own show called Celebrity Practical Jok'd. The group gets overly paranoid that one of them will join Chad to set up a prank and begin setting pranks for each other.