After they squabble over a video-gaming system, Nico and Grady declare they are no longer best friends. They each choose Sonny as their new best friend, and she is forced to endure their childish behavior.

Sonny and Tawni are invited to appear on the talk show Gotcha with Gilroy Smith. They soon discover that Gilroy aims to trick them into revealing embarrassing secrets, even going so far as to invite Chad Dylan Cooper to the show.