When someone begins to spread rumors that Sonny is a thief and evidence begins to emerge showing that she not only stole her sketch ideas, but also things from her friends, her reputation begins to deteriorate and Sonny is asked to leave So Random.

Sonny meets her childhood hero, Pauly the Polar Bear, and tries on his costume. She is tricked by the actor who plays Pauly, Hank, into wearing the costume during a publicity meeting with children at the studio, and inadvertently misses her seven-week anniversary dinner with Chad.