Mitch tries to negotiate a car deal for Russell, and an opportunity for a great deal presents itself when a gay salesman assumes Mitch and Russell are a couple. Meanwhile, Tracy and Angie set out to save money at the gym.

Mixed-faith couple Mitch and Tracy struggle to teach their daughter about religion and life's biggest questions. Meanwhile, Mitch's sister arrives for dinner with her psychic boyfriend, and Angie and Russell clash over God.