The fun begins when a cast-off cast member from Rachel's season of The Bachelorette washes up with a date card burning a hole in his pocket. Later, one frustrated female, who doesn't know where she stands with her man, makes it clear she would love to go on a date with the newcomer. During the cocktail party leading up to the first rose ceremony, one guy tells one of the women he wants to slow things down. The morning after, one lucky loser receives a rose from a buddy rather than from his prospective bride, and one woman's pretty boy shows up with a birthday cake for someone else!

Tonight's wildly entertaining episode of Bachelor in Paradise, begins, ironically, with the arrival of a virgin with a date card. Although her "friend" from Nick's season of The Bachelor warns the virgin that her man would be a "waste of time" asking, he lets her know that, despite what she might have heard, he would love to go on a date with her. And so he does. At the rose ceremony, one man, who is interested in two women, has to choose one to give his rose to, knowing that the other one will probably be going home, while another man finds himself torn between the "right option" and the "more exciting option."