Two new men arrive, promptly choosing a pair of lucky ladies to take on a hot and heavy double date; things fall apart as one hopeless romantic learns the object of his affection visited the boom boom room with someone else; guest host Lance Bass.

Joe comes face-to-face with the woman who broke his heart; Natasha and Brendan start to move in the right direction, but just as Natasha feels the spark heat up, another familiar face makes her appearance.