While in New York City, Leah and Angelo are excited to show Sofia where they grew up, even if Sofia isn't! Angelo secretly plans an emotional reunion between Leah and her biological father. At home, Vicki's dog wreaks havoc in Leah's absence.

Leah is upset that she doesn't have a signature dish at Vivian's; so she decides to have a cooking competition with the family to see who gets the next special on the menu.