When Dave gets hit on by an attractive saleswoman at work, he believes he is still a catch for the younger ladies. However, he is quickly brought back to earth when he finds out she was actually checking him out for her mother. On the other hand, Vicky attracts males of all ages when she visits Mike's class for career day and Hillary is attracted to Kenny's sensitive side.

When Hillary sprains her ankle skiing and lands in the emergency room, a furious Dave becomes even angrier when he realizes Vicky gave her approval for the ski trip without his consent. But when they arrive at the hospital and learn that Hillary lied to the both of them, their argument turns into an all-out war. Meanwhile, Larry awaits a phone call from a girl and Mike takes advantage of the situation to get an older woman.