Vicky invites Taye's family over for a barbecue, but Dave doesn't get along with Taye's father, Omar, who's a wealthy, well-educated, African-American surgeon, and Dave ends up offending him with what are perceived as racist comments. At Vicky's insistence, Dave apologizes to Omar and has a great day at Omar's exclusive country club, only to find out when he gets home that Hillary and Taye's relationship is on the rocks. Meanwhile, Mike is worried when blisters appear on his penis and Dave's remedy for what is determined to be chronic masturbation only makes things worse.

When Hillary's friend gets breast implants, Hillary wants them, too. Dave and Vicky are against the idea, as Dave argues that it's what you're like on the inside that counts. However, his motto is tested when he meets Larry's new girlfriend, Marla, who is overweight and not particularly attractive. As a result, Dave struggles between convincing his daughter that appearance isn't everything and telling his son he can do better.