Dave is tired of Larry and Mike's constant fighting and suggests that Mike try harder to have a relationship with his brother. Much to Dave's disappointment, Mike actually prefers hanging out with Larry to practicing for basketball tryouts, and worries that Larry's nerdy ways are starting to rub off on him. Meanwhile, Hillary sets out to prove she's more than just a pretty face by trying to get a blind guy interested in dating her.

Kenny moves in to the Gold house and Vicky promptly sets out to redecorate the basement for him but her ideas don't meet his standards. Larry, Hillary and Mike try to get Kenny to tone it down and stop doing chores and laughing at Dave's bad jokes, as it's showing them up. Meanwhile, Dave lets everyone at work know he's taken in the orphaned gay kid so that he he'll look like a good guy and hopefully get the newly vacant, larger office.