Caught between their new professional lives and their old student lifestyle, quirky accountants Robert and Marie may be ready to move on but their disheveled home is holding them back. With water damaged floors, confused rooms, and a master bath turned storage area, the property is unsellable. In order to leverage its value, Jonathan comes up with a plan to breathe fresh life into the home. A single tile proves to be a costly setback, and when Drew finds them a rare showpiece, the couple gambles on a short sale to land a great new home.

With a rambunctious toddler and another baby on the way, Halley and Justin urgently need a more child-friendly home. But they can't even list their current property until they undertake a major overhaul. Drew and Jonathan are determined to help them move on and come up with a strategy. But once the walls come down, the problems start piling up as Jonathan uncovers a major leak, faulty wiring, mold, termite damage, and a rat's nest. The couple is overwhelmed by the news and the skyrocketing price tag. As for finding them a new property, Drew struggles to get Halley and Justin on the same page.