Tickle unearths an exceptional source of spring water for Josh's peach brandy. Tim sets out to resurrect a spirit that fueled America's most intoxicated president. Mike convinces Richard to ignore an extortion attempt and risk angering a local mob boss.

When Amanda tracks down a lost apple variety once famous for making outlaw brandy, she and Kelly turn out an extraordinary liquor that Mark and Digger find themselves too deep in the bottle. Tim and Howard invent a novel double-distilling device.