Shep tries to charm his way out of the doghouse with his girlfriend, Taylor. After an apology tour, Kathryn continues to face backlash for her exchange on social media. Austen refuses to accept that his relationship with Madison is over, pushing Craig to make an unexpected, last-ditch effort to help his friend.

It's sink or swim on the two-part season finale opener, as Pringle and Shep cohost a "good times" pool party. Leva finally calls out the boys on their unyielding defense of Kathryn, and questions if they know all sides to the story. And while Craig may have found his storybook romance, Austen looks to close the chapter on Madison for good.