The holiday season is off to a rocky start when the gang gets together for a Friendsgiving feast; Austen hosts and leaves certain people off the guest list; a newly single Kathryn searches for things to be grateful for; Paige comes to town.

Shep tries to right his wrongs from Auldbrass and invites the gang on a trip to St. Simons Island, but his efforts are in vain when his emotions get the best of him. Austen expresses concern for Taylor's future with Shep. Craig loses his temper when Naomie's actions bring up wounds from the past.