When a seller brings an E.T. printer's proof movie poster into the shop, Chum phones his resident expert for advice. Will he be able to make an out-of-this-world deal? Then, Rick and Corey take a Civil War rifle out to the range. Will they see double when the seller tries to make an offer? After, Rick investigates a dog-shaped diamond, but will the deal be all bark and no bite? And later, is it a bird? Is it a plane? It's a Superman pinback! Can Chum save the day, or will the deal go "up, up, and away?"

Rick checks out a horde of coins from Kentucky -- but is all that glitters gold, or will Rick be played for a fool? Then, Chum gets into the spirit when a mentalist brings in a magical clock.  Will it be time for a deal, or will Chum get ghosted?  Later, Corey isn't ready to say die to a deal when a seller brings in a poster from The Goonies -- but will this be treasure, or will Corey be cursed? And finally, Chum tries to drum up a deal on a sparkling snare. Will the seller feel the rhythm, or will Chum have to tap out?