When a customer walks into the shop with a camera that shot the first footage of Elvis, will Rick and Corey shake up a good deal, or will they return to sender? Then Chum tries to dig up some info on a mysterious fossil. Is it a dinosaur egg, or will Chum end up with egg on his face? Then Rick tries to strike black gold with a Standard Oil stock certificate. Will he buy low and sell high or will the market crash? And finally, Corey chomps his teeth into some Holyfield/Tyson tickets.

A seller comes into the shop with some chef whites signed by the actor who played the iconic Soup Nazi on Seinfeld. Will Rick and Chum say "No deal for you!" or will they reach an agreement on price? Then, Corey tries to make a surreally good deal on a Dali lithograph from a collaboration with Walt Disney. And later, Rick goes back to school when a seller brings in a signed page from James Dean's yearbook. Will he rebel against the asking price, or will it be a giant score?