The bachelorettes select two lucky guys for their most important one-on-one dates yet; a "cheesy" weightlifting competition; Gabby and Rachel are tasked with making tough decisions at the rose ceremony with many uncertainties still in the air.

Rachel and Gabby reunite with 14 of the most unforgettable men from the season; Gabby and Rachel answer burning questions from their former flames and welcome actors Billy Eichner and Luke Macfarlane to the stage to join in on the action.