In this episode, the Cold Justice team is back in small town America where they hope to uncover the truths behind a mysterious death of a young man that occurred just a few years ago. Kelly, Yolanda, and Detective Orlando Martinez will be working with state police and firearm experts from across the country to try and get to the bottom of what really happened.

In this two-part episode, the Cold Justice team heads to White Settlement, Texas, to investigate two different murder cases at the same time. A 1992 sexual assault and murder of a woman who was stabbed to death in her home and a double homicide of two young men whose throats were slashed. Both crimes happened within months of each other and in the same greater neighborhood leaving local law enforcement with three unsolved murders. The team will have to determine if these two cases are potentially connected.