The team follow a temporal aberration to 1967 and find their former captain Rip Hunter... with no memory of who he is, and directing a student film. Damien and Malcolm arrive due to the Medallion, and the Legends soon realize that they're after something that Rip has... even if he doesn't know it.

The Legends trace a timequake to Christmas Day, 1776... and discover that George Washington has been killed. They try to save Washington's life but the mission goes awry when Mick is captured by the British, Sara is shot, Ray is trapped at six inches, and Nate and Amaya are the only ones left to track Mick and the missing Washington.