In the Old West, Orange and the gang stumble across a town populated entirely by fruit! But the peaceful residents are shakin' in their boots when a villainous band of Pasta-leros rides into town. With no one else to stand up to the spaghetti outlaws, Orange has to pin on the sheriff's badge. Will he still be standing at high noon? Or will the bandits get the drop on him?

The rest of the fruit won't let Orange join their glee club, so he settles for babysitting duties and teaches a fresh young orange to be annoying. But the rejection continues when the fruit invite the little cutie to join and tell Orange to take a hike! He finds acceptance in a commune of organic bohemian produce, but where will his loyalties lie when the peace-loving protesters occupy the fruit cart?