Guy Fieri discovers Hunter and Antonia Lofaso holding an all-star competition featuring his least favorite food; the chefs try to get Guy to take bites of egg-heavy dishes for points and entice the judges with meals made from unpopular ingredients.

Guy Fieri brings back four chefs who came close to victory their first time in Flavortown Market to prove the second time's a charm. In round one, the chefs must use ingredients that took them down last time to make a redemption dinner! Then in round two, each chef determines their own fate by using ingredients that all start with the letter of their choice. The winner will claim their comeback and finally shop Flavortown Market for up to $20,000.