Lou finds herself trapped at the Dude Ranch with Mitch, the new ranch hand, and they both reveal the circumstances of their recent pasts. While helping Amy treat a client horse, Ty feels conflicted about opening a mysterious package that has ties to his troubled past. And Jack and Lisa cope with a health scare, while Georgie and Adam deal with the fallout from Adam's kiss with another girl.

When their plans to get away are thwarted, Amy and Ty celebrate their first anniversary closer to home and Amy unveils a special surprise. Meanwhile, Peter lobbies for a reunion forcing Lou to make a difficult decision about her and her family's future. While her parents grapple with their decision, Georgie has to act quickly on a trail ride when she learns a secret about Adam that leaves his life hanging in the balance. And Ty steps up to convince the devastated Bob to reconsider when he decides to throw in the towel at the Wildlife Reserve.