The first Hathaway/Preston Yard Sale is smooth sailing until Louie fumbles his attempt to possess a stuffed animal, landing himself in Taylor's favorite nurse doll. The kids must all work together to get him back home safely.

Frankie fakes an injury to stay out of a play that Michelle is directing for school. Unfortunately, her plan backfires when Louie takes her place and does so well that she is jealous and must fight to get her spot back.