Barnaby is forced to shoot and kill a boy his own age who took a woman and her daughters hostage. He is cleared of any wrongdoing but cannot shake the blood he feels is on his hands plus the judge wants him to inform the boy's mother.

Coop tells Bill the story of the Earp brothers and the Silver Lady, a woman who was encased in a coffin of silver coins that melted around her after the stagecoach she was riding on and guarded by Morgan Earp had an accident and burned.