Chloe and Ava find out that they both had a fling with the fiancé of one of their clients, Emerson Ives, who thinks that her fiancé is a virgin like she is. Ava also goes to a fertility specialist with her husband, Lola tries to re-enter the dating world, and Chloe finds out that no man has ever been "that into her."

Lola, Chloe and Emerson sign up for an Internet dating service. Lola pretends that she's a gay man after she sees her ex-husband on the website.