It's Christmas on Long Island and in true holiday fashion, Theresa spreads the gift of giving when she brings her family to volunteer at a local soup kitchen. When spirit interrupts Theresa's philanthropy, a skeptic is left in absolute shock.

Victoria tries to use her charm to finagle a car from her parents. Theresa is vehemently against the idea, but her husband Larry is on the fence. Also, Theresa helps a young woman reconnect with her father that died tragically.