While Mel and Harry try to crack the Book of Elders, Macy struggles with the good and bad aspects of her demon side. Maggie competes with Jordan for a promotion. Macy ventures out alone and meets an injured and terrified witch named Abigael. Mel and Harry visit another dimension.

Mel and Maggie attempt to find a missing Macy with a spell while Harry uses a different method - allowing Abigael to help him access his subconscious in an attempt to connect with his dark side.