Rhyme knows that this summer is going to be a bust. All of her friends are on vacation or at dance camp—without her—and T. K., her maybe boyfriend, is away all summer in LA. But when an enigmatic set of twins rolls into town, looking for answers and acceptance, Rhyme gets caught up in a decades-old mystery of love, intrigue, and danger.

Attaway's pageant for boys has Ezra, Hamilton, Jax (Alex Guzman), and Tim vying for the title of Mr. Attaway. While competition heats up on-stage, off-stage, Rhyme and Rooney begin reconsidering the state of their relationships.