The group tries to be there for Sophie as an upcoming father-daughter dance recital approaches, and when she asks a very reluctant and arrhythmic Eddie to dance with her, it leaves Delilah feeling uneasy. Against her better judgment, Maggie agrees to have Rome in for a therapy session, but it quickly becomes clear that her new friendships are a conflict of interest. Meanwhile, Danny confesses a secret to Gary; Maggie receives an unexpected visitor from her past; and someone discovers a cryptic voicemail from Jon that was left right before he died.

The aftermath of Eddie and Delilah's secret takes a toll on everyone in the group, including the future of Delilah and Regina's restaurant. Maggie and Gary's relationship is tested when an old fling turns up, and Delilah struggles with the balance of protecting her children and keeping Jon's memory alive.