A letter from Ward Beech in Socorro, NM states he was being held for murder but he was sleeping it off in Troop's jail on that same date. When he rides there to investigate, he finds more than the sheriff is willing to hide what happened.

Troop befriends a convict he jailed. When the driver of the stage he's riding shotgun on is killed, talk is he's picked up his old ways with the old gang. With a posse on the hunt for them, the gang figures they can pick the town clean.

Jack Rollins, a famous gunfighter, comes to town on some personal business. When Troop finds out what that is he intervenes to make sure Jack's reputation doesn't hurt someone he says he cares for very much.

The buffalo hunters are stirring up trouble with the Shoshone. Troop fears a bloodbath when a man is hung and he is closely related to the tribe. It isn't until later he learns just how close.

An Army Colonel's son, who only wants to pursue a writing career and not a military one. Troop is given 24 hours to find him or he will be charged with desertion. A demoted sergeant wants revenge and does all he can to "help" the boy.

Wrongly accused a thief, Bill Andrews is locked up trying to defend himself. With a bad family history, no one seems willing to vouch for him except his longtime friend Johnny McKay who puts his own reputation and badge on the line.

A bounty hunter brings a body into Laramie to collect the fee. He finds out that another wanted man may be hiding out under another name. He sets his sights on taking him in even though Troop has said "no more business for bounty hunters."

The verdict is in - Kate Wilson is once again found not guilty of a crime. If the marshal has any say, her feminine charms have been wielded at the male population one too many times because he has a plan.

A vilified man is in Laramie. It's up to Troop to get Bob Ford on the 4pm train before he is killed or lynched by the good citizens, who have nothing good even to sing about him.

Marshall Troop takes two men to the territorial prison. One a doctor and the other to be hanged. When they run across a stage that's lost a wheel, the doctor must decide between helping a murderer go free or the oath he took as a doctor.

A stranger rides into town, playing jokes on the locals and a story about Johnny's dad who he always believed was shot by raiders. The story he's told causes him to quit his job until Troop discovers the real history his deputy never knew.