The brothers go to a wake to pay their respects to a dead wrestler who was John's favorite, and discover that the show has left a trail of bodies behind it. Meanwhile, Crowley escapes from Hell and goes to get a weapon capable of stopping Lucifer.

Sam and Dean save a couple from two werewolves, but Sam is shot in the process. Dean tries to get Sam and the couple to safety, but Sam dies... and Dean is forced to abandon him.