Sam and Dean get a call on one of Mary's phones from Alicia Banes. Alicia and Max are looking for their mother Tasha, and the trail leads to a boarding house in Wyoming. Meanwhile, Mary discovers that Ketch has been lying to her.

Sam and Dean try to escape the bunker after Ketch turns it into a deathtrap. Meanwhile, the brainwashed Mary goes after Jody and Alex, and Hess puts Phase Two of the Brit's plan into action.