When Sam and Dean go missing, Jody calls in Claire. The two of them, along with Patience, Alex, Kaia, and Donna, set out to find the Winchesters in the Bad Place and free them before the portal closes. However, creatures that have come through the portal have other ideas.

Two young witches use a love spell to get what they want... and they want the Black Grimoire stored at the bunker. Meanwhile, Lucifer and Castiel try to escape from Asmodeus' imprisonment, and are forced to work together.