An artist turns up dead, his eyes burned out, and the Winchesters suspect that Jack was responsible. However, they soon discover that Jack is trying to help them by finding a dreamwalker so that he can locate Mary for the brothers.

Donna's niece Wendy goes missing near a truck stop, and she calls on the Winchesters for help. They soon discover that Wendy's abductor is part of an online business providing food to monsters.