When Chuck expresses his feelings about his complicated relationship with Sarah, a heartless female agent named Alex Forrest is sent to evaluate Sarah's performance as Chuck's handler. Morgan, Jeff and Lester try to weasel their way into getting invited to Awesome's bachelor party.

After Chuck's father Steve is kidnapped by Fulcrum, Chuck learns the only chance he has to find him is by putting his trust and life into the hands of the person he trusts the least; his ex-girlfriend Jill Roberts. Meanwhile, the Buy More team tries to sabotage Emmett's corporate evaluation.