Dylan discovers why ex-girlfriend Phoebe hasn't been returning his messages. Later, Luke urges Dylan to confess his love to Evie.

Dylan's visit to Bethany recalls a dinner with her intimidating big brother, while Luke tries to learn why his female co-workers all hate him.

The show flashes back three years to a birthday dinner between Evie and Dylan that comes undone. Meanwhile, Dylan reconnects with Abigail.

While Luke puts the moves on a childhood crush at a swanky party, Dylan and Evie cure their boredom by running through items on Luke's bucket list.

While visiting Anna, Dylan recalls a disastrous double date with Luke, who was trying to keep Anna's classmate, Cleo, from discovering his shallowness.

Dylan relives a nightmarish encounter from three years ago when he visits Abigail, the first on his alphabetical list of past conquests.