Joining Joel McHale are contestants Krystal Harris (hometown: Grass Valley, California), Aaron Arguilera (hometown: Orange, California), Kristina Garcia (hometown: Glendale, California) and Levon Turner (hometown: Compton, California).

Joining host Joel McHale are contestants Aswan Harris (hometown: Cleveland, Ohio), Chris Carter (hometown: Santa Barbara, California), Dylan Patterson (hometown: Valencia, California) and Diane Dowler (hometown: Kansas City, Missouri).

Joining Joel McHale are contestants Mike Mador (hometown: Hermosa Beach, California), Thais Bouchereaux-Paytner (hometown: Brooklyn, New York) and Derek Arteta (hometown: Covina, California) and Nina Lalezari (hometown: Los Angeles, California).

Joining Joel McHale are contestants Tamika Lamison (hometown: Richmond, Virginia), Bryce Clifford (hometown: Lake Forest, California) and Malenda Pillow (hometown: Temecula, California) and Ashley Dos Santos (hometown: Los Angeles, California).