Emotionally ready to confront her fiancé's 15-year-old murder, Hailey finds herself caught up in the case of a missing college coed. The deeper Hailey digs into the young woman's disappearance the more she is convinced the two events are related.

Hailey's professional code of ethics prevents her from going to the police about a client's confession, so she must find another way to bring the killer to justice.

When Hailey attends her niece's school recital, she learns that the beloved music teacher has vanished. Hailey soon discovers several startling secrets amongst the staff.