Colter heads to Willow Creek, Mich., after a worried mother hires him to track down her beauty queen daughter, Riley, who vanished while driving home from work. While investigating at the garden center where Riley works, Colter looks into her modeling past and uncovers that she was hiding a major secret.

Colter returns to Echo Ridge to investigate a diner owner's disappearance, only to uncover a kidnapping ring and a shocking family secret.